THREE TESTS THAT WILL SAVE
BILLIONS OF DOLLARS AND REDUCE ETHNIC HEALTH DISPARITIES. Victor
Herbert, M.D., J.D, Tracy Stopler, M.S., R.D., Department of Veterans
Affairs-Bronx V.A. Med. Ctr. & Mt. Sinai-New York University Health
System.
Most
adult Americans have health check-ups including blood drawn to assay for
anemia or diabetes, but almost never for iron, transcobalamin II
B12 (TC II B12) (holo TC II) or folate, even though these 3 assays are
more often abnormal, and more often trigger effective therapy.
Making them part of routine screening will sharply reduce ethnic
disparities in health, allowing corrective therapy to prevent genotype
(genetic predisposition) from becoming phenotype (disease), protecting
millions from early morbidity and mortality. One in 8 of all
Americans, and 1 in 3 African-Americans daily absorb too much dietary
iron (i.e. have genetic hemochromatosis [GH]). This GH frequency
coincides with greater frequency of diabetes, heart disease, and cancer
in African-Americans. People with GH suffer insidiously
progressive multiple-organ damage (diabetes from pancreas iron,
cardiomyopathy and arrhythmias from heart iron, cirrhosis and cancer
from liver iron, etc). This is prevented by getting rid of the
accumulating extra iron by phlebotomy (giving a unit of blood) 3-4
time/yr
(V Herbert. Blood 11/99). Caution: Contrary to buzzword
antioxidant claims, vitamin C pills of 100 mg or more, taken daily by 30% of Americans,
drive free radical generation from iron, promoting cancer and fatal
cardiac arrhythmias in GH (V Herbert. Ann Int Med, Sept. 1999).
High serum homocysteine (Hcy) is associated with vasculo-and neuro-toxicity.
Most high Hcy results from deficiency of B12 and/or folate and/or B6.
Premenopausal black women have higher Hcy, lower folate, and
2-3-fold more coronary artery disease (CAD) than white women
(Gerhard et al. AJCN 1999; 70:252). When a gene for gastric atrophy is
expressed (in the fertile years in black females [V Herbert, 1999.
EDITORIAL: http://www.harrisonsonline.com])
and somewhere between age 50 and age 90 in almost everybody else) one
can no longer absorb food B12. Within a week of no absorption of B12,
blood serum holo TC II, a circulating protein which delivers B12 to
surface receptors of all DNA-synthesizing cells, becomes low, diagnosing
that B12 is no longer being absorbed and gut, blood and nerve cells are
becoming deficient. Misleadingly, total serum B12 remains normal.
Jacques et al found (NEJM 1999;340:1449) that, while fortification of
grains with PGA (folic acid) in elderly adults increased serum folate
and decreased serum Hcy, the difference in mean Hcy was largely due to
differences in use of B vitamin supplements. This supported our studies
that, by age 65, 49% of healthy elderly had low holo TC II, 60% of
this 49% had high serum Hcy (>17), and supplementation with100mg of
crystalline B12 orally daily normalized holoTC II and Hcy (V Herbert.
Blood 11/99). Low folate in elderly may be largely B12 deficiency
gut damage causing malabsorption of folate (and B6), corrected by B12
therapy. A 5-yr delay in heart disease onset will save $69
billion/yr (J. Davis, Letter, NY Times, 8/11/99). We petitioned RHW FDA
to require addition of B12 to all folate fortification or
supplementation; Surg Gen Satcher agrees. National Institute on Aging's
Dr. Longo supports our recommendation that all Americans take 100 mcg
daily oral crystalline B12 starting at age 50. Black females should
start at age 25 (for the reason stated above).